The motions of individual stars in the core of Omega Centauri, a massive globular cluster, confirm the existence of a black hole at its core.

It’s at least 8,200 times as massive as our Sun, and it’s less than 18,000 light-years away. According to a new study, a giant black hole lurks in the very center of the massive globular cluster Omega Centauri — a prominent naked-eye object in the southern sky.

Omega Centauri zoom
A three-panel zoom into a new colored Hubble image of Omega Centauri, with the likely position of the intermediate-mass black hole marked with a dashed circle.
ESA / Hubble & NASA, M. Häberle (MPIA)

A team led by Maximilian Häberle (Max Planck Institute for Astronomy, Germany) found seven stars in the globular’s core that move so fast that they would have escaped the cluster altogether if not for the additional gravity of a massive central object. “It’s a beautiful measurement,” says dynamicist Simon Portegies Zwart (Leiden Observatory, The Netherlands), who was not involved in the study.

If confirmed, Omega Centauri’s black hole would be one of the first convincing examples of an intermediate-mass black hole (IMBH). These black holes are much more massive than the stellar variety left behind by supernova explosions, but nearly not as hefty as their supermassive siblings in the centers of galaxies.

In the past, spectroscopic measurements of stars’ velocities in the cores of globular clusters had already hinted at the presence of IMBHs in Omega Centauri, 47 Tucanae, and M15, among others. “What’s spectacular here,” says Portegies Zwart, “is that they have measured velocities of individual stars.”

Häberle and his colleagues meticulously measured the motions of 1.4 million individual stars in more than 500 archival Hubble Space Telescope images of Omega Centauri taken over the past 20 years. Close to its center, they found seven stars that moved more than 2.41 milli-arcseconds per year across the sky. At the cluster’s distance of 17,700 light-years, that proper motion corresponds to a projected velocity of more than 62 kilometers per second (140,000 mph) — the estimated escape velocity of the globular’s core if it doesn’t contain a black hole. The fastest star of the batch has a proper motion of 4.41 milliarcseconds per year, corresponding to a projected velocity of 113 kilometers per second.

After zooming into the Omega Centauri globular cluster, an animation shows the movement of stars near the cluster center.

The discovery of those seven speedy stars requires the presence of something massive — a compact object that would raise the velocity required to escape the core, Häberle’s team explains in this week’s Nature. From the observed motions, the researchers deduce the compact object’s mass must be at least 8,200 times that of the Sun. (Since only motions in the plane of the sky can be measured, the true velocities of the stars through space are probably higher, which would also imply a higher black hole mass.)

This is only the second time that researchers have derived the existence of a massive black hole from the motions of individual surrounding stars, the first one being the Nobel Prize-winning measurements of massive stars swirling around Sagittarius A*, the supermassive black hole in the center of our Milky Way Galaxy.

In this video, Häberle's team shows visually how the Hubble data was collected over the course of two decades.

Portegies Zwart says Häberle and colleagues are “absolute experts” in this field; however, he remains a bit cautious about the team’s conclusions. “We don’t know the cluster’s escape velocity very precisely,” he says. “Suppose it’s 80 kilometers per second instead of 62 — that would leave only two stars moving faster, one of which might be a non-related foreground object. You wouldn’t have a strong case then.”

The authors agree that it would be great to also determine radial velocities (the speeds of the stars toward or away from us rather than across the sky). They’ve already secured observing time on the James Webb Space Telescope to do so. More (and more precise) positional measurements of the fast-moving cluster stars could also reveal the expected curvature of their paths, due to their orbital motion around the black hole. “I’d love to see a true orbit,” says Portegies Zwart.

The presence of an intermediate-mass black hole in Omega Centauri would bolster the theory that the globular cluster is actually the stripped nucleus of a small galaxy that was devoured by our Milky Way in the distant past. That merger would have stopped the growth of that galaxy’s central black hole. The discovery is thus not only interesting in its own right, it could also shed light on the evolution of black holes in low-mass galaxies.

Comments


Image of Martian-Bachelor

Martian-Bachelor

July 18, 2024 at 10:52 pm

> the motions of 1.4 million individual stars

I don't see why a black hole is required. Seven stars out of this many might be able to achieve such velocities through mutual close approach gravitational interaction with other stars. The stars have escape velocities but just haven't escaped yet.

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Image of Monica Young

Monica Young

July 19, 2024 at 11:21 am

This is a great point! The Nature paper actually does address this (you can find a detailed explanation in the eighth part of their Methods section: https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-024-07511-z#Sec2). The upshot is that, to explain these fast-moving stars via ejections by three-body interactions, there would need to be an unexpectedly high ejection rate. That would be true not just for the center but also at larger radii — and they don't see enough fast-moving stars farther out from the center. Also, such a high ejection rate would deplete the stars in the cluster within 2.5 billion years, and the cluster is older than that. The conclusion is that while a three-body interaction might explain a star or two, it can't explain all seven fast-moving stars, so at least some of these must be in orbit around the center.

You must be logged in to post a comment.

You must be logged in to post a comment.